America's Favorite Sterling Silver Jeweler
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR EMAIL LIST
You have 0 item(s) in your Shopping Cart Checkout
Sale Items
Select a Sub-Category or Item:

Christmas is a favorite holiday for most people, especially when silver jewelry is wrapped as Christamas gifts under the tree.  Over 125 pages of choices include silver chains, gemstone jewelry, silver rings, necklaces, and  over 8,000 other items from which to choose.  There is a special gift for everyone on your list within the pages of the Plum Island Silver catalog.



P-20853 <br>STERLING SILVER DOVE INSIDE HEART CHARM
P-20853
STERLING SILVER DOVE INSIDE HEART CHARM
Price: $13.60 

P-20929 <br>STERLING SILVER FILIGREE ANGEL PENDANT WITH HEART
P-20929
STERLING SILVER FILIGREE ANGEL PENDANT WITH HEART
Price: $8.85 

P-20985 <br>STERLING SILVER FILIGREE ANGEL EARRINGS WITH HEART
P-20985
STERLING SILVER FILIGREE ANGEL EARRINGS WITH HEART
Price: $13.30 

P-20805 <br>STERLING SILVER REVERSIBLE SNOWFLAKE CHARM
P-20805
STERLING SILVER REVERSIBLE SNOWFLAKE CHARM
Price: $26.90 

P-20806 <br>STERLING SILVER ANGEL CHARM HOLDING HEART
P-20806
STERLING SILVER ANGEL CHARM HOLDING HEART
Price: $37.30 

P-20807 <br>STERLING SILVER HEART SHAPE ANGEL WINGS CHARM
P-20807
STERLING SILVER HEART SHAPE ANGEL WINGS CHARM
Price: $17.65 

P-20810 <br>STERLING SILVER PEACE DOVE CHARM WITH OLIVE BRANCH
P-20810
STERLING SILVER PEACE DOVE CHARM WITH OLIVE BRANCH
Price: $20.80 

P-20811 <br>STERLING SILVER HIGH POLISH HEART CHARM
P-20811
STERLING SILVER HIGH POLISH HEART CHARM
Price: $14.50 

P-20812 <br>STERLING SILVER CLUSTER OF HEARTS CHARM
P-20812
STERLING SILVER CLUSTER OF HEARTS CHARM
Price: $35.70 

P-20499 <br>STERLING SILVER 17"-18" ADJUSTABLE MICRO PAVE CUBIC ZIRCONIA CURVED BAR NECKLACE WITH SNOWFLAKE
P-20499
STERLING SILVER 17"-18" ADJUSTABLE MICRO PAVE CUBIC ZIRCONIA CURVED BAR NECKLACE WITH SNOWFLAKE
Price: $18.35 

P-20503 <br>STERLING SILVER MINI MICRO PAVE CUBIC ZIRCONIA SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
P-20503
STERLING SILVER MINI MICRO PAVE CUBIC ZIRCONIA SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
Price: $11.40 

P-20517 <br>STERLING SILVER 16"-17" ADJUSTABLE YELLOW GOLD TONE ANGEL WING NECKLACE WITH CUBIC ZIRCONIAS
P-20517
STERLING SILVER 16"-17" ADJUSTABLE YELLOW GOLD TONE ANGEL WING NECKLACE WITH CUBIC ZIRCONIAS
Price: $20.95 

P-20487 <br>STERLING SILVER PRANCING REINDEER CHARM
P-20487
STERLING SILVER PRANCING REINDEER CHARM
Price: $16.90 

P-20414 <br>STERLING SILVER 18" SNOWMAN PENDANT NECKLACE WITH BLUE AND WHITE BEADS
P-20414
STERLING SILVER 18" SNOWMAN PENDANT NECKLACE WITH BLUE AND WHITE BEADS
Price: $38.30 

P-20017 <br>STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE MINI BIRD PEACE DOVE CHARM
P-20017
STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE MINI BIRD PEACE DOVE CHARM
Price: $9.20 

P-20018 <br>STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE BIRD PEACE DOVE CHARM
P-20018
STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE BIRD PEACE DOVE CHARM
Price: $12.70 

P-19811 <br>STERLING SILVER ANGEL WING EARRINGS
P-19811
STERLING SILVER ANGEL WING EARRINGS
Price: $23.40 

P-19812 <br>STERLING SILVER GINGERBREAD MAN CHARM
P-19812
STERLING SILVER GINGERBREAD MAN CHARM
Price: $17.75 

P-19813 <br>STERLING SILVER CANDY CANE CHARM
P-19813
STERLING SILVER CANDY CANE CHARM
Price: $13.05 

P-19814 <br>STERLING SILVER SMALL SNOWFLAKE CHARM
P-19814
STERLING SILVER SMALL SNOWFLAKE CHARM
Price: $18.05 

P-19815 <br>STERLING SILVER LARGE SNOWFLAKE CHARM
P-19815
STERLING SILVER LARGE SNOWFLAKE CHARM
Price: $34.75 

P-19816 <br>STERLING SILVER SNOWMAN CHARM
P-19816
STERLING SILVER SNOWMAN CHARM
Price: $19.55 

P-19817 <br>STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM WITH STAR
P-19817
STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM WITH STAR
Price: $15.95 

P-19912 <br>STERLING SILVER 18" SNOWFLAKE PENDANT NECKLACE WITH BLUE RIVERSTONE BEAD
P-19912
STERLING SILVER 18" SNOWFLAKE PENDANT NECKLACE WITH BLUE RIVERSTONE BEAD
Price: $25.40 

P-19539 <br>STERLING SILVER 3D PRAYING ANGEL CHARM
P-19539
STERLING SILVER 3D PRAYING ANGEL CHARM
Price: $16.95 

P-19540 <br>STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE ANGEL WITH TRUMPET CHARM
P-19540
STERLING SILVER SILHOUETTE ANGEL WITH TRUMPET CHARM
Price: $14.20 

P-19541 <br>STERLING SILVER ANGEL WITH TRUMPET PENDANT
P-19541
STERLING SILVER ANGEL WITH TRUMPET PENDANT
Price: $32.00 

P-19542 <br>STERLING SILVER GREEN AND RED CANDY CANE CHARM
P-19542
STERLING SILVER GREEN AND RED CANDY CANE CHARM
Price: $8.95 

P-19543 <br>STERLING SILVER WHITE AND RED CANDY CANE CHARM
P-19543
STERLING SILVER WHITE AND RED CANDY CANE CHARM
Price: $9.35 

P-19544 <br>STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE ORNAMENT CHARM WITH SNOWFLAKE
P-19544
STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE ORNAMENT CHARM WITH SNOWFLAKE
Price: $9.70 

P-18888 <br>STERLING SILVER NORTH STAR CROSS CHARM
P-18888
STERLING SILVER NORTH STAR CROSS CHARM
Price: $17.55 

P-18780 <br>STERLING SILVER OUTLINE CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM
P-18780
STERLING SILVER OUTLINE CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM
Price: $16.50 

P-18484 <br>STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 12 POINT SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
P-18484
STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 12 POINT SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
Price: $12.20 

P-18485 <br>STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 6 POINT SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
P-18485
STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 6 POINT SNOWFLAKE EARRINGS
Price: $10.15 

P-18489 <br>STERLING SILVER SMALL DIAMOND CUT 4 POINT SNOWFLAKE CHARM
P-18489
STERLING SILVER SMALL DIAMOND CUT 4 POINT SNOWFLAKE CHARM
Price: $7.55 

P-18491 <br>STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 6 POINT SNOWFLAKE PENDANT
P-18491
STERLING SILVER DIAMOND CUT 6 POINT SNOWFLAKE PENDANT
Price: $12.60 

P-17693 <br>STERLING SILVER PRAYING ANGEL WITH HALO PENDANT
P-17693
STERLING SILVER PRAYING ANGEL WITH HALO PENDANT
Price: $9.80 

P-17694 <br>STERLING SILVER OPEN CROSS WITH ROSE PENDANT
P-17694
STERLING SILVER OPEN CROSS WITH ROSE PENDANT
Price: $14.50 

P-17023 <br>STERLING SILVER CUBIC ZIRCONIA STAR BURST EARRINGS
P-17023
STERLING SILVER CUBIC ZIRCONIA STAR BURST EARRINGS
Price: $40.95 

P-16417 <br>STERLING SILVER 7.5" HAMMERED CROSS BRACELET
P-16417
STERLING SILVER 7.5" HAMMERED CROSS BRACELET
Price: $46.10 

P-16418 <br>STERLING SILVER 7.5" MOM WITH HEART BRACELET
P-16418
STERLING SILVER 7.5" MOM WITH HEART BRACELET
Price: $46.10 

P-16080 <br>STERLING SILVER ROUND CROSS CUT OUT CHARM
P-16080
STERLING SILVER ROUND CROSS CUT OUT CHARM
Price: $11.95 

P-13697 <br>STERLING SILVER WHITE ENAMEL WINTER MITTEN CHARM
P-13697
STERLING SILVER WHITE ENAMEL WINTER MITTEN CHARM
Price: $15.95 

P-13701 <br>STERLING SILVER JOY SLIDE PENDANT IN SCRIPT
P-13701
STERLING SILVER JOY SLIDE PENDANT IN SCRIPT
Price: $15.30 

P-13706 <br>STERLING SILVER PLAIN TINY CROSS CHARM
P-13706
STERLING SILVER PLAIN TINY CROSS CHARM
Price: $5.65 

P-13707 <br>STERLING SILVER ENAMEL SNOWMAN WITH BLACK HAT CHARM
P-13707
STERLING SILVER ENAMEL SNOWMAN WITH BLACK HAT CHARM
Price: $11.80 

P-11596 <br>STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM WITH SWAROVSKI CRYSTALS
P-11596
STERLING SILVER CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM WITH SWAROVSKI CRYSTALS
Price: $13.90 

P-16061 <br>STERLING SILVER DOUBLE SIDED HEART PICTURE FRAME CHARM
P-16061
STERLING SILVER DOUBLE SIDED HEART PICTURE FRAME CHARM
Price: $17.75 

PN-386 <br>STERLING SILVER SIDE VIEW GUARDIAN ANGEL PIN
PN-386
STERLING SILVER SIDE VIEW GUARDIAN ANGEL PIN
Price: $15.30 

CH-1891 <br>STERLING SILVER SMALL SHINING STAR PENDANT
CH-1891
STERLING SILVER SMALL SHINING STAR PENDANT
Price: $7.90 

CH-2390 <br>STERLING SILVER MEDIUM SHINING STAR PENDANT
CH-2390
STERLING SILVER MEDIUM SHINING STAR PENDANT
Price: $11.20 

CH-2391 <br>STERLING SILVER LARGE SHINING STAR PENDANT
CH-2391
STERLING SILVER LARGE SHINING STAR PENDANT
Price: $25.50 

CH-2395 <br>STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED THREE DIMENSIONAL NUTCRACKER CHARM
CH-2395
STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED THREE DIMENSIONAL NUTCRACKER CHARM
Price: $9.45 

CH-2941 <br>STERLING SILVER ENAMEL BLUE SNOWFLAKE CHARM WITH BLUE CRYSTAL
CH-2941
STERLING SILVER ENAMEL BLUE SNOWFLAKE CHARM WITH BLUE CRYSTAL
Price: $13.50 

CH-2950 <br>STERLING SILVER ENAMEL 3D RED CHRISTMAS LIGHT BULB CHARM
CH-2950
STERLING SILVER ENAMEL 3D RED CHRISTMAS LIGHT BULB CHARM
Price: $11.15 

CH-3076 <br>STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED TRIPLE HOLLY LEAF WITH BERRIES CHARM
CH-3076
STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED TRIPLE HOLLY LEAF WITH BERRIES CHARM
Price: $10.10 

CH-3156 <br>STERLING SILVER PEACE DOVE OUTLINE CHARM WITH OLIVE BRANCH
CH-3156
STERLING SILVER PEACE DOVE OUTLINE CHARM WITH OLIVE BRANCH
Price: $9.05 

CH-3164 <br>STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED ANGEL CHARM WITH HARP
CH-3164
STERLING SILVER ANTIQUED ANGEL CHARM WITH HARP
Price: $13.55 

EA-3399 <br>STERLING SILVER SMALL ANTIQUED CELTIC CROSS FRENCH WIRE EARRINGS
EA-3399
STERLING SILVER SMALL ANTIQUED CELTIC CROSS FRENCH WIRE EARRINGS
Price: $17.15 

CH-3477 <br>STERLING SILVER CONTEMPORARY SQUIGGLE CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM
CH-3477
STERLING SILVER CONTEMPORARY SQUIGGLE CHRISTMAS TREE CHARM
Price: $12.35 

P-11104 <br>STERLING SILVER MINI LITTLE DONKEY EARRINGS ON STAINLESS STEEL POSTS AND NUTS
P-11104
STERLING SILVER MINI LITTLE DONKEY EARRINGS ON STAINLESS STEEL POSTS AND NUTS
Price: $11.40 
     
BACK TO TOP OF PAGE